Best MacBook Pro alternatives

As much as some of us may deride the MacBook Pro for its awful keyboard, annoying Touch Bar and overreliance on USB-C connections, its balance of screen quality, weight, battery life and performance had no Windows-based peer for a long time. But now that OLED displays have hit the market, that balance is tipping. OLED delivers true blacks, which means high contrast, as well as a wide gamut of colors and high dynamic range that can rival or outperform the MacBook’s Retina Display.

We’re just getting a sense of what the new M1-chip-based 13-inch MacBook Pro has to offer compared with Windows alternatives, so I’m sticking with my original picks for the moment. Performance is good, but there are still some compatibility issues — plus Apple’s jacked up the prices of the Intel-based models — which make it less of a slam dunk relative to Windows systems than it might otherwise have been.

Stay in the know

Get the latest tech stories with CNET Daily News every weekday.

The 16-inch MacBook Pro also changed things up a bit. It’s still the size of the 15-incher but slightly heavier and ditches the butterfly-switch keyboard in favor of a slightly better scissor-switch-based one (I still don’t like it). It’s basically the same, however, and still with no 4K options. On the other hand, like its predecessors, its performance beats similarly configured Windows systems on a lot of tasks.

But even an entry-level MacBook can stretch the limits of your budget, and those who’ve set aside a nice chunk of cash might want something a little more customizable. No one can deny that one appealing thing about Windows laptops is the variety. Even when trying to imitate the offerings of a MacBook (heck, or even an iPad or iPad Pro) there are all sizes of far less expensive Chromebooks, as well as 14- and 15-inch laptops that are slightly smaller and lighter than the 16-inch MacBook Pro, but not quite as small as the 13-inch MacBook Air, across the price spectrum. Plus, we’re seeing lots of experimentation with multiscreen designs.   

Lori Grunin/CNET

If, like me, you’re not a fan of OLED screens for photo editing — they’re not optimized for Adobe RGB and aren’t great at tonal range in the shadows — then what you need is a laptop with a good IPS display. The Dell XPS 17 9700 with the 4K screen option delivers that, and it’s not as reflective as the OLED screens I’ve seen. Dell’s PremierColor software isn’t perfect, but it gives you more control over screen settings than most I’ve seen, and it’s got two Thunderbolt 3 controllers to make your external drives happy. It’s heavier than the MacBook, but not much bigger, especially given its larger 17-inch screen. And while its battery life isn’t terrific, its performance can certainly keep up.

The Razer Blade Pro 17 is a strong runner-up here if you’re willing to trade higher performance and a similar design for a bigger, heavier model.

Read our Dell XPS 17 9700 review.

Sarah Tew/CNET

If you’re drawn to a MacBook Pro for its featureless-slab aesthetic, Razer’s your Windows go-to. If you want one that matches the 13-inch Pro for design, size and weight, the Stealth is your option. 

It’s priced similarly to the Intel-based MacBook Pro options, and should provide better performance than the Intel models — we’re still figuring out comparisons between the M1 Macs and Windows systems — since it incorporates discrete GeForce GTX 1650 Ti graphics.

Read our Razer Blade Stealth (2019) review.

Josh Goldman/CNET

Dell’s XPS 13 is a 13.3-inch laptop that’s so trimmed up that the body is basically the size of an older 11.6-inch laptop. Being part of the company’s XPS line means both its chassis and components are top-notch for its class, so you’re getting great battery life and performance, too. Power delivery is via USB-C and it comes with a microSD reader and headphone jack. It comes in both a standard clamshell as well as the two-in-one, but I prefer the two-in-one because you can fold it up into a tablet if you’ve got to work in a cramped space.

Read Dell XPS 2-in-1 review.

Josh Goldman/CNET

What’s better than the Touch Bar? An entire half-screen second display, that’s what. The Duo’s tilt-up second screen can act as an ancillary display, an extension of the primary display (for viewing those long web pages) or a separate control center from which you can run Asus’ custom utilities or as control surfaces for select creative applications. Plus, Asus excels at squeezing every bit of performance out of its high-end laptops, and the 14-inch delivers great battery life, as well. 

It comes in two models, the 2019 Pro Duo 15 OLED we reviewed and the 2021 14-inch Duo 14. The Pro Duo 15 OLED will have up to a 10th-gen Intel Core i9 processor, with an Nvidia GeForce RTX 3070 discrete graphics and up to 32GB of memory when it arrives in April. The Duo 14 has either 11th-gen Core i5 or i7 processors, optional Nvidia MX450 discrete graphics and up to 32GB of memory.

Read more

Now playing:
Watch this:

Hands-on with the entire new Apple Mac M1 lineup


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *